FUDGE FLAVORS

Generation after generation, our fudge makers are required to learn the secrets of producing perfect fudge. Each batch starts in a copper kettle and is painstakingly created with attention to indoor, outdoor and marble countertop temperatures, and length of time/temperature required for cooking, boiling, stirring, cooling and shaping.

*** All Fudge is Gluten Free.
Order minimum 3 or 5 slices
Click below to order!

Order Now

SHARK BITE

Vanilla Fudge with cherries and a hint of cranberry. Just in time for the 50th anniversary of the release of JAWS, shot right here on Martha’s Vineyard. Enjoy a bite of the Shark…Bite!

SHARK BITE

Vanilla Fudge with cherries and a hint of cranberry.

BUTTER PECAN

With the same type of texture and creaminess that you’d find in a good cheesecake, our Butter Pecan gets the faintest amount of crunch from a healthy dose of pecans. Notes of brown butter and vanilla round out the bite.

CHOCOLATE MINT

Bright and herbal, our Chocolate Mint has notes of citrus right up front. The refreshment of the mint sends a chill straight down to your taste buds while an underlying hint of rich, dark chocolate creates balance in every bite.

CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER

There are two well-defined textures in our classic Chocolate Peanut Butter combination: the soft, nutty peanut butter layering against the firmer chew of chocolate. The two mingle together perfectly — not too sweet with just a hint of salt.

CHOCOLATE PECAN

Not even a pecan-laced brownie can match our Chocolate Pecan in flavor and richness. A bite starts with the very gentle give of the exterior followed by the smooth interior laced with chopped pecans. The nuts also add a hint of earthiness that balances out the chocolate.

CHOCOLATE WALNUT

Distinctly nutty and earthy, our Chocolate Walnut delectable bite is packed with chunks of walnut, which offer a nice foil to the dark, bitter sweetness of the chocolate base.

CRANBERRY

DOUBLE CHOCOLATE

Like a freshly made chocolate soufflé, our bold and Double Chocolate dose satiates every type of chocolate craving. There are deep, unending layers of cocoa plus a lingering slick of fresh cream.

PEANUT BUTTER

Like a bite of peanut butter straight off the spoon, our Peanut Butter fudge hits you right in the comfort zone. Glossy and smooth, a piece of this fudge offers a subtle touch of that nutty, familiar flavor.

PLAIN PENUCHE with NUTS or without

Enjoy the delightful sweetness of Plain Penuche, a classic treat that melts in your mouth. Choose the nutty version for added crunch or the smooth, nut-free option for pure buttery flavor. Perfect for sharing or savoring alone, this confection satisfies your sweet cravings!

PLAIN CHOCOLATE

Few things can satisfy a sweet tooth like pure chocolate — and that’s what our traditional, plain Chocolate fudge delivers. With each bite you get an addictively dense hit of straight milk chocolate flavor that, like any good chocolate, coats the tongue with cream and lingers for a long, sweet finish.

PLAIN VANILLA

We find so much beauty in this pure and simple bite of our Plain Vanilla fudge. Like a snow-white frosting, this bite offers up a rich, almost tangy sweetness that’s reminiscent of farm-fresh cream combined with the exotic aroma of vanilla bean.